Suzanne, we did have an experience like that once where we were told no early embarkation available in San Juan. We were staying across the street at Sheraton, so we walked over and got right on (paid the $100 pp). Next time in San Juan, we just went over. Then in Dubai, we loved our hotel too much to attempt early check-in, but others did it. I don't know if they booked it in advance or not.
The choice of toiletries came about when they took away the Bvulgari for Aqua de Parma and many were disappointed and made a huge deal of it. Then they started it back with a choice and added on Neutrogena. I like the Bvulgari best because the Aqua has a stronger scent.
I think the reason I like the service better on SS is it is a little more formal.
I'm interested in how Shadow compares to my experiences on the 3 other SS cruises we've had in the last 2 yrs. I am hoping it will be great with this being the end of the world cruise.
Tomorrow we opted for all-inclusive at The Verandah for the night, so we probably won't try to board early. We will see how we like The Verandah, and if unhappy will just go to the pier. I don't know how many booked 3809B vs. 3809, so I don't know if they are going to charge to board early or not.
I agree about the free internet, though I am not getting it yet on Regent. I spend hundreds on internet just so I can share my pics (and do other things, of course). I wish SS had this perk.