This is my first time on the internet since leaving home. Loved reading all the interesting and worthwhile posts. On the basis of my experience on Whisper, I'd rate rate Regent and Silversea excellent and relatively equal. IMO, Silversea beats Regent in the areas of service and the travel desk. The service on Whisper was awesome. When we boarded, we found our forward cabin a bit too warm and asked that the air conditioning be checked out. It was checked out and proved to be ok. The next morning, when we returned to our cabin from breakfast, all three pairs (yes, pairs) of cabin attendants who worked the deck 8 cabins saw us and stopped what they were doing to ask us about the status of our air conditioning--all three. They ALL knew us and went out of their way to show they cared. That night, our second night on the ship, I walked into the Panorama Lounge after the show to order a cognac. It was placed in front of me in thirty seconds. My response: "That was fast." The waitress casually replied: "the bartender saw you walk in." Wow! By this time, by the way, we were regularly addressed by name by most of the crew members who dealt with us regularly.

I have found the tour desk on Regent ships to be the weak spot. The clerks seem bored and neither interested nor well informed about scheduled port stops and available excursions. The Whisper tour desk, in contrast, was excellent. The staff were involved, well informed, personable, and highly visible on the ship's tours doing their best keep folks happy. They made a real difference and a highly positive impression.

In most other respects, I found the Whisper experience to match the excellence I have enjoyed on Voyager and Mariner. The one problem on Whisper was, as others have correctly reported, the inconsistent galley. Lots of the Silversea regulars we talked to said this was unique to this executive chef and an exception to the rule.

It was a wonderful trip with excellent traveling companions. I hope to post a full review sometime soon.

Patrick