Just logging on and doing some catch up reading.
Naturally the first few days were spent making comparisons. Points given and taken away to both cruiselines in various categories.
I had the total opposite experience as Debbie in regard to first day check in. The actual check in experience was relatively the same other than a small line created by the fact we were told that early check in was not available in Dubai, so most pax arrived at the same time. Suzie and Marilyn requested it months early and were denied, Fred and Pat contacted the port agent the day of embarkation and were told "no problem". But, I digress... Olivia's and my luggage entered the ship on the same luggage cart. She found hers on the packing mat in her room just after check in while mine went AWOL for over two hours and then was left outside my door.
When my cabin attendent stopped by to introduce herself with the tray of choices of bathroom ammenities (that is a nice touch), she looked into my bathroom, clutched her throat and let out a throaty "Oh my gawd" (you fill in the Romanian accent). I thought I had somehow missed seeing the body in the bathtub that would warrent such a reaction. There were not only no ammenities in my bathroom, but no towels or toilet paper. Needless to say, after she regained her composure, she sent her partner to rememedy the situation. No biggie really, but not the best first impression. After that I had to canvas the rest of the group to learn what was actually supposed to be part of the bath set-up. Shower caps are rationed out, or at least at the end of my corredor. It took a request to the Head Honcho Housekeeper to get one (and then my "girls" tossed it two days later with no replacement, again, no biggie, but many of you have not seen what happens to my hair in humidity).
The service is markedly more formal, which is not necessarily a bad thing. I do like the 24 hour coffee corner on Regent. There is a machine in the morning in the lounge on deck 8, but it is taken away at 11am sharp. If you want a little fruit or perhaps a pastry, there is no self service selection, instead a three tiered tray of goodies is brought to you like high tea. Again, this is lovely, but I only wanted a slice of pineapple.
My impression is also that the staff are more polished on SS, but as others have mentioned, the dining room always seems to be short-staffed and the wait personnel could benefit from roller skates. Today at lunch it was a good half hour between wineglass top ups and that was after a request. Our waiter and waitress were looking quite stressed and were skipping around to try to keep up. The service was very good, but they just needed more bodies.
There are obviously some issues with the A/C, but that happened on the Navigator in February as well. The Panorama lounge on 8 is stiffling with the humitity of Bangkok, while "The Bar" on 5 is like a fridge. But as that is consistant, we bring a wrap for trivia.
As others have said and I will echo, aren't we pretty darn lucky to have choices at all, and choices such as these? I'm just pleased as punch to be here and would not hesitate to rebook!