Hi Debbie!

I agree with many of your observations. You are very experienced on SS and that is most helpful. Right price, right itinerary and I'd happily sail SS again. Thank you for taking the time to delineate the differences!

This is simply a first-time impression so take it in that vein. SS tries to do more in the way of personal service. When executed smoothly, it's really, really good. When there's a miss, it's a bigger miss than I'm used to on Regent.

This sailing is quite full so perhaps missed steps are more apparent? For me, that comes across as greater inconsistency. Last night was a repeat of our previous dining experiences .. two mains were stunningly delicious, two were poor. The staff went out of their way to assist with our camel race party. They were simply terrific, and obviously cared a lot to get it right. I don't think they'd seen anything quite like it, and enjoyed being a part of our fun. That effort and care will win me over in a heartbeat.

So ... we have yet another day to enjoy a lovely cruise.