I am sure my opinions being just the opposite are no surprise. While I like aspects of Regent better and some other aspects of Silversea better, we have found quite a few things (and most of those mentioned here) better on Silversea. I have not been on Mariner, though. I have not found the embarkations of Regent to be at all up to par with SS except for being allowed on at noon without paying. I consider that a huge plus of Regent. However, on Regent, nobody assists with hand luggage or getting to the room, and bags are outside vs. on the bed waiting like SS>
I have found service almost non existent during the day on Regent unless you sit right near to a wait station, which I try to do when I seat myself (unlike SS where someone takes my plate and seats me).
Also, in my comparisons I noted that I found no breads of any type on either Regent cruise at breakfast and assumed even toast and bagels were to be ordered. On SS, at the buffet, there is an area for that, and you ask them for it, and they bring it to your table. I did notice on the last Whisper that the buffet had gone down, but I still like the fruit carving.
Also, I much prefer the closet on Whisper but the couch on Voyager and Navigator. Why even in a Medallion, SS has that stuby loveseat, I don't know.
I've found plenty of great itineraries on SS - going to Africa, Seychelles, Madagascar, Reunion Island and Mauritius quick cheaply over Christmas and New Years 2009 and found their Asia offerings more comprehensive than Regent's in 2009. For 2008, I prefer Regent's itiineraries, and their 2008 Christmas offerings on Voyager are far superior to Silversea's Christmas 2008 offerings for length, cost, etc. at least for our needs.
I found now that the staff in Silversea has become more Asian than European, the service is not as top-notch and over the top as it was, but it is still great and excels on the pool deck and in the public areas. I like Voyager for the dining choices are food creativity. Menus on SS haven't changed much since I got the menus from Kristin on her first SS cruise. I'm almost planning in my head what I will have next week on Shadow whereas I still count on Regent to surprise me a little.