Wow, what a coincidence! So you are/were in the theatre biz. It is a very respectable theatre, but I see that right now a revival of Hair is playing. Not sure how you feel about that. They have another stage, Canstage Berkeley, which is a smaller venue I think.
The other big musical is LOTR, a hugely expensive musical, but it has had mixed reviews. Not sure if you want a musical, or something more "off broadway", as it were. If so, Theatre Passe Muraille is the oldest, mostly Canadian plays. Factory Theatre is another good small theatre, and Tarragon as well.