Luxury Cruise Talk Logo

Keene Luxury Travel
800-856-1155 · 972-701-9292
Join Our Mailing List · Email us

Who's Online Now
0 registered members (), 58,841 guests
Newest Members
marg, Matthew_Corps77, JLdB, Obiliro, ConnorWood(41385 Registered Users)
Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Camel: Comparing Silversea with Regent #186716 04/22/08 06:26 PM
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 1,434
Dreps Offline OP
cruiser
OP Offline
cruiser
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 1,434
I thought it would be interesting to post my thoughts on a comparison of Silversea with Regent thus far. For background, note that we’ve been on the Mariner for 47 days and the PG for 24. While we haven’t been on the Voyager, I am aware of most of the physical differences with the Mariner. First, I’ll start chronologically with our pre-cruise.

As you may know from my blog, we began with a 3 night pre-cruise in Cairo, and it was handled excellently. The transfer agents and the guide were both terrific. Of course, we were only six people, and it was like having a private tour. If one compares it with our overnight excursions on PANDA, I think it compares favorably, realizing that tourism in Egypt is not up to the standards of that in even the less sophisticated cities of Xian and Guilin in China.

The transfer to the ship and boarding were fairly effortless—very similar to Regent. Not only was champagne available when we boarded, but a nice spread with shrimp, smoked salmon, etc., was in the room where we registered, and I grabbed a quick nosh, having only had 2 breakfasts (including an odd one on Egypt Air). Then we went up to the cabin and only waited a short time for our luggage. (We had boarded about 4:00 PM.)

Our cabin 712 is a veranda suite toward the front. So far, as Ngaire mentioned, seas have been pretty calm so I can’t comment much on movement. As most of you know, the cabin itself is very similar to those on the Voyager and the Navigator. As you can see on the Silversea site, the furnishings are very similar with blonde woods, mirrors, etc. What I find interesting is that even in comparison to the smaller Mariner cabin, the space on Silversea is not as efficiently utilized. There are less exposed shelves and drawers, and some that do exist are fairly useless because of their size. For example, there are small end tables next to the little sofa in the sitting area that have tiny drawers on top and a false bottom, and I have no idea what’s in that space. (There are also similar end tables on either side of the bed, but they have just one larger space in each, with no shelves.) There is also less drawer space around the desk. The new flat screen TV is nice, but there is a lot of wasted space behind it now. With regard to the bathroom, I’m somewhat of a heretic in that I don’t care about the separate shower because it is very small and there is only a very tiny area on which one can put shampoo, conditioner and soap, so I find it just as convenient to shower on the Mariner since I’m only 5’8”. The double sinks are nice, but quite frankly, we seldom use the bathroom at the same time. There have been several times that hot water has been a problem, and I’ve heard several other Camelites with the same issue. I’m not sure what’s going on with that. Some love the bedding, some find it a bit soft. Thus far, I think it’s fine.

Our cabin steward and her assistant are Filipino. Regina seems to be one of the best we’ve ever had. She’s pleasant, outgoing, and I enjoy interacting with her. The first thing she did was ask what exactly we wanted in the mini-bar. (I think I wasted my time filling out a specific request on the guest information form.) The mini-bar was restocked later that evening. I also asked her for a little pair of scissors to use during the cruise because I forgot to pack one, and I think she loaned me her own pair. The veranda is very similar to the one on the Mariner.

The food is hard to assess so far. The first dinner was definitely the least good meal. As I mentioned in Seamail, I ate the mussels for an appetizer and that was a big mistake, as I really think I had some sort of adverse reaction. Not food poisoning, but more of an allergic reaction. My main course of tuna was okay, nothing great. The second night—the Captain’s Welcome dinner—was superb with lobster as the featured entrée, but many of us had appetizer portions so we could also have prime rib as the main course. The chocolate dessert with a variety of confections was also very tasty. The duck entrée last night was also very good. My appetizer of king prawn and scallop ravioli was less exciting. Most of us ordered Grand Marnier soufflés, which you actually ordered after the meal, and they varied tremendously. Most seemed somewhat undercooked. Lunches have been fine. We’ve gone to La Terrazza and one day there was a salmon en croute that was particularly good. Yesterday, they were carving a pork roast, which others said was excellent. Gail and I stuck to the Italian dishes: lasagna, pizza, eggplant, etc. Desserts have been good at lunch and similar to Regent, but instead of labeling each one, Silversea puts up a dessert card with a list, which makes it sometimes tricky to identify which is which. Breakfast is similar to Regent, though not quite as good so far. I really like Muesli, and despite the more International nature of Silversea, I find it inferior. One thing several of us really don’t like is that you line up for your food in an area of La Terrazza at the side. It’s almost like going into a back room, and there is essentially a single line. This makes things much less efficient than the duplicate set-ups on Regent. As far service, I think the personnel are very friendly, but I also have the impression they are stretched a little thinner than on Regent. They sure seem to hustle a lot, but I don’t think there as many bodies to see after things.

We haven’t done a real excursion yet, so I can’t compare that aspect with Regent. One also has to recognize, that these countries are much less used to tourism, so the infrastruture is just not there for Silversea to call upon.

Regarding the other passengers, as you would expect, there are far more International guests on board. I haven’t decided what I think about that yet, though my initial impressions are that it is not particularly a plus.

That’s all I can think of for now. I’ll add my further thoughts as the cruise progresses.

Added: We decided to try breakfast in The Restaurant because we’re not arriving in Salalah, Oman until noon, and they don’t seem to have pancakes, French toast, etc. on the buffet (though I’m sure you could order them there). It was very empty at the main restaurant. We ordered and received our fresh orange juice, promptly and it was delicious (as it had also been in La Terrazza). I had a bit of a communication problem trying to find out if one could get something other than the rye French toast on the menu. Eventually, Gail had waffles and the waiter brought me both French toast and my second choice, blueberry pancakes. I didn’t care much for the French toast, which I think ended up being made with white bread but had an usual flavor (perhaps from cooked mangoes on it), though I’m not sure. Everything else was fine, but the real problem is that it took about 45 minutes for our food to arrive. Mind you, there weren’t more than 5 occupied tables in the whole restaurant. From now on, I think we’ll stick to the buffet in La Terrazza and possibly try room service.


--------------

Eugene

Re: Camel: Comparing Silversea with Regent #186717 04/23/08 02:47 AM
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 522
Luke Offline
cruiser
Offline
cruiser
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 522
Thanks for the insights and comparisons. Please continue to report your "findings."


Luke
Re: Camel: Comparing Silversea with Regent #186718 04/23/08 02:49 AM
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 2,447
Sue&TomInGeorgia Offline
cruiser
Offline
cruiser
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 2,447
Eugene thanks for taking the time to do this comparison. We have not sailed Silversea yet, so I am always curious to hear what others have to say. Our neighbors were on Silversea the week before last and they said hands down they preferred Regent.

It is nice to have the choice, if we so want it, but I think we may stick with Regent (unless Silversea has an itinerary that can't be beat). :)


Sue
"A vacation is having nothing to do and all day to do it in" Robert Orben
*******
Re: Camel: Comparing Silversea with Regent #186719 04/23/08 03:13 AM
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 5,658
cruisinfanatic Offline
cruiser
Offline
cruiser
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 5,658
Thanks Eugene for those interesting comparisons. We too have been interested in possibly sailing Silversea, but so far haven't found the right combination of price and itinerary. Maybe someday.


JoAnn
Re: Camel: Comparing Silversea with Regent #186720 04/23/08 08:57 AM
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 2,512
azgkrudi Offline
cruiser
Offline
cruiser
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 2,512
Eugene, your comparisons are very similar to my thoughts on the two lines. I think if we had sailed Regent before Silversea, we would have been a little disappointed in Silversea. But having sailed Silversea several times before we tried Regent, we thought SS was the be-all and end-all. I am honestly VERY GLAD that we tried Regent, and they have now become #1 with us. Like the others here have said, if we find that "just right" itinerary on SS, we will return. But for now, Regent suits us to a "T".

Enjoy, and keep posting your thoughts as you go along - I appreciate it very much!


Kristin

Paul Gauguin's Tere Moana-12/14
Voyager-10/08, 11/10
Navigator-05/07, 5/09, 10/11
Paul Gauguin-6/06, 12/07
Silver Shadow-12/06
Silver Whisper-11/05, 12/04
Silver Wind-4/04
Re: Camel: Comparing Silversea with Regent #186721 04/23/08 10:32 AM
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 569
DebbieH103 Offline
cruiser
Offline
cruiser
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 569
I am sure my opinions being just the opposite are no surprise. While I like aspects of Regent better and some other aspects of Silversea better, we have found quite a few things (and most of those mentioned here) better on Silversea. I have not been on Mariner, though. I have not found the embarkations of Regent to be at all up to par with SS except for being allowed on at noon without paying. I consider that a huge plus of Regent. However, on Regent, nobody assists with hand luggage or getting to the room, and bags are outside vs. on the bed waiting like SS>

I have found service almost non existent during the day on Regent unless you sit right near to a wait station, which I try to do when I seat myself (unlike SS where someone takes my plate and seats me).

Also, in my comparisons I noted that I found no breads of any type on either Regent cruise at breakfast and assumed even toast and bagels were to be ordered. On SS, at the buffet, there is an area for that, and you ask them for it, and they bring it to your table. I did notice on the last Whisper that the buffet had gone down, but I still like the fruit carving.

Also, I much prefer the closet on Whisper but the couch on Voyager and Navigator. Why even in a Medallion, SS has that stuby loveseat, I don't know.

I've found plenty of great itineraries on SS - going to Africa, Seychelles, Madagascar, Reunion Island and Mauritius quick cheaply over Christmas and New Years 2009 and found their Asia offerings more comprehensive than Regent's in 2009. For 2008, I prefer Regent's itiineraries, and their 2008 Christmas offerings on Voyager are far superior to Silversea's Christmas 2008 offerings for length, cost, etc. at least for our needs.

I found now that the staff in Silversea has become more Asian than European, the service is not as top-notch and over the top as it was, but it is still great and excels on the pool deck and in the public areas. I like Voyager for the dining choices are food creativity. Menus on SS haven't changed much since I got the menus from Kristin on her first SS cruise. I'm almost planning in my head what I will have next week on Shadow whereas I still count on Regent to surprise me a little.

Re: Camel: Comparing Silversea with Regent #186722 04/23/08 12:03 PM
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 2,447
Sue&TomInGeorgia Offline
cruiser
Offline
cruiser
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 2,447
That is what is great about having the choice to pick Regent or Silversea...some like R while others prefer SS.

Just think if we all liked the same cruise line or there was only one to pick from all the cruises would be sold out and we'd be sailing on TUSH! :ohmy: :p


Sue
"A vacation is having nothing to do and all day to do it in" Robert Orben
*******
Re: Camel: Comparing Silversea with Regent #186723 04/23/08 03:47 PM
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 11,641
joannapv Offline
cruiser
Offline
cruiser
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 11,641
Thanks Eugene - agree with Sue - nice to have choices -


Joanna
Re: Camel: Comparing Silversea with Regent #186724 04/24/08 07:07 AM
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 569
DebbieH103 Offline
cruiser
Offline
cruiser
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 569
Yes, and two such good ones. Just like hotels, I wish I could have all my favorite things of each all in one place. It never happens.

Re: Camel: Comparing Silversea with Regent #186725 04/24/08 06:40 PM
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 4,215
adrenn Offline
cruiser
Offline
cruiser
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 4,215
Hi Debbie!

I agree with many of your observations. You are very experienced on SS and that is most helpful. Right price, right itinerary and I'd happily sail SS again. Thank you for taking the time to delineate the differences!

This is simply a first-time impression so take it in that vein. SS tries to do more in the way of personal service. When executed smoothly, it's really, really good. When there's a miss, it's a bigger miss than I'm used to on Regent.

This sailing is quite full so perhaps missed steps are more apparent? For me, that comes across as greater inconsistency. Last night was a repeat of our previous dining experiences .. two mains were stunningly delicious, two were poor. The staff went out of their way to assist with our camel race party. They were simply terrific, and obviously cared a lot to get it right. I don't think they'd seen anything quite like it, and enjoyed being a part of our fun. That effort and care will win me over in a heartbeat.

So ... we have yet another day to enjoy a lovely cruise.

Re: Camel: Comparing Silversea with Regent #186726 04/24/08 08:41 PM
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 1,434
Dreps Offline OP
cruiser
OP Offline
cruiser
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 1,434
Here are some further impressions:

As those of you who are following our blog will know, we did a half-day excursion in Salalah, Oman. On the basis of that one data point only (and we’ll have more), I would say that it was comparable to a Regent excursion. I certainly believe that in this part of the world, it is more challenging for the cruise lines to obtain the quality of land-based operations that are available in many other places. Nevertheless—and we may have lucked out—we had an excellent guide on our tour. He apologized often for his English, when, in fact, it was very good. The bus was very comfortable, and we had actually changed from another one that seemed to have less good A/C so that most of the Camel passengers could be together. That also added to the enjoyment. I am also somewhat biased in evaluating the excursion because during our last stop at the bazaar, the guide went out of his way to help me find a garment and hat for my costume for the Camel races in the space of 10-15 minutes. I felt somewhat guilty monopolizing his time, although our fellow passengers were also busy shopping.

Most of the staff have been very friendly. I presented one of the wait staff—a young woman from Romania—who had admired my magnetic Camel pin with an honorary one, and now I think I have a friend for life. I continue to think that the staff in the dining rooms are spread more thinly than on Regent. Our cabin stewardess remains one of the best we’ve ever had.

More on food, which probably is the most subjective area of comparison. One thing I like is that each night when we receive the Chronicles for the next day, it includes menus for both lunch and dinner. On every other ship we’ve been on, I usually anxiously wait for the menus to be posted—but than I’m a bit of a “foodie.” On the other hand, I wish we could have booked the alternative restaurant online, because by the time one sees the menu, it’s too late to get a reservation at one of them. For us, that really means La Terrazza, because I doubt we’ll pay the supplement for Le Champagne. It’s $200 per person for a meal with wine pairings. If one foregoes the one it’s only $30 per person. However, the kicker is that if you want any wine, you must purchase it, and the bottles start in the $50 range. I’m sure we’d go if we could just purchase a glass of wine each, but we don’t really think it’s worth spending over $100 when there are two very good alternative restaurants where there is always something good. The food itself continues to be comparable to Regent, in my opinion—especially dinners. Neither is totally consistent. I do miss the daily specials at breakfast on Regent. In addition, I’d probably give Regent an edge at lunches. Dinner last night was somewhat mixed. Ngaire and I had identical meals: An asparagus/spinach tart (like a quiche), lemon sole (which actually was an appetizer portion of a main course), and a prime rib eye steak. The fish was really delicious. My steak was way beyond medium rare, and even its replacement, which came in less than 5 minutes, was still overcooked. In part, this was because all of them were fairly thin. Death by chocolate for dessert was so-so. The wines have been quite good, and if one pour doesn’t hit the spot, it’s easy to get another.

Entertainment. We’re not big on going to the shows. So far, we’ve only attended an Italian magician, and a singer who “impersonates” the style of Barbra Streisand. The magician was okay. The singer was very good. Gail thought she was one of the best acts she’s ever seen on a ship. I’m a harsher critic, and though I admit that she was good, when you take on Streisand, it’s a tough challenge.

I’ve attended a couple of lectures, in part, because someone raved about the lecturer. My gripe was that the lecture was supposed to be all about Saudi Arabia, and, in fact, only 5 minutes at the end (out of 45) was devoted to the country. I became bored by the content and pace of the talk. Perhaps the ship and the lecturer didn’t communicate properly.

I sure miss the free Internet on Regent. Yesterday, we did not have service most of the day (which I realize has also happened on Regent ships). Nonetheless, I’d sure enjoy browsing the Internet more, if I weren’t paying for it. It’s been especially costly in trying to solve my problems with posting many pictures.

I’m sure I’ll have some further thoughts, but that’s it for now.

-------------

Eugene

Re: Camel: Comparing Silversea with Regent #186727 04/25/08 03:28 AM
Joined: May 2004
Posts: 709
Freddie Offline
cruiser
Offline
cruiser
Joined: May 2004
Posts: 709
I agree with many of the points posted by Anne and Eugene, with the notable exception that we have had excellent (and fast) service each morning at breakfast in The Restaurant. We've had breakfast there each of the last five mornings and have not had any delays whatever in either the taking of our orders or the delivery of the food. I've already posted on the other thread about the ghastly eggs benedict the first morning and the fact that the EB has been excellent the last four mornings.

We find that on balance, the food is equivalent (some hits and some misses) on this ship and on Regent Voyager.

Our two cabin attendants are marvelous - friendly, attentive, and fast.

If forced at gunpoint (or at the point of a champagne bottle cork) to choose between the two lines for service, I'd give the slight nod to SS. The staff is remarkably amiable and eager to help.

We love this ship and are having a grand time.

Re: Camel: Comparing Silversea with Regent #186728 04/28/08 04:13 AM
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 2,026
Fogmalkin Offline
cruiser
Offline
cruiser
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 2,026
Just logging on and doing some catch up reading.

Naturally the first few days were spent making comparisons. Points given and taken away to both cruiselines in various categories.

I had the total opposite experience as Debbie in regard to first day check in. The actual check in experience was relatively the same other than a small line created by the fact we were told that early check in was not available in Dubai, so most pax arrived at the same time. Suzie and Marilyn requested it months early and were denied, Fred and Pat contacted the port agent the day of embarkation and were told "no problem". But, I digress... Olivia's and my luggage entered the ship on the same luggage cart. She found hers on the packing mat in her room just after check in while mine went AWOL for over two hours and then was left outside my door.

When my cabin attendent stopped by to introduce herself with the tray of choices of bathroom ammenities (that is a nice touch), she looked into my bathroom, clutched her throat and let out a throaty "Oh my gawd" (you fill in the Romanian accent). I thought I had somehow missed seeing the body in the bathtub that would warrent such a reaction. There were not only no ammenities in my bathroom, but no towels or toilet paper. Needless to say, after she regained her composure, she sent her partner to rememedy the situation. No biggie really, but not the best first impression. After that I had to canvas the rest of the group to learn what was actually supposed to be part of the bath set-up. Shower caps are rationed out, or at least at the end of my corredor. It took a request to the Head Honcho Housekeeper to get one (and then my "girls" tossed it two days later with no replacement, again, no biggie, but many of you have not seen what happens to my hair in humidity).

The service is markedly more formal, which is not necessarily a bad thing. I do like the 24 hour coffee corner on Regent. There is a machine in the morning in the lounge on deck 8, but it is taken away at 11am sharp. If you want a little fruit or perhaps a pastry, there is no self service selection, instead a three tiered tray of goodies is brought to you like high tea. Again, this is lovely, but I only wanted a slice of pineapple.

My impression is also that the staff are more polished on SS, but as others have mentioned, the dining room always seems to be short-staffed and the wait personnel could benefit from roller skates. Today at lunch it was a good half hour between wineglass top ups and that was after a request. Our waiter and waitress were looking quite stressed and were skipping around to try to keep up. The service was very good, but they just needed more bodies.

There are obviously some issues with the A/C, but that happened on the Navigator in February as well. The Panorama lounge on 8 is stiffling with the humitity of Bangkok, while "The Bar" on 5 is like a fridge. But as that is consistant, we bring a wrap for trivia.

As others have said and I will echo, aren't we pretty darn lucky to have choices at all, and choices such as these? I'm just pleased as punch to be here and would not hesitate to rebook!


Suzanne
Re: Camel: Comparing Silversea with Regent #186729 04/28/08 08:04 AM
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 5,658
cruisinfanatic Offline
cruiser
Offline
cruiser
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 5,658
Love your story about the room stewardess and her reaction when looking into your bathroom Suzanne. I am still sitting here chuckling and trying to imagine what you must have thought she saw in there. Very funny and you told it so well!

Glad you are having a good time. :app: :app:


JoAnn
Re: Camel: Comparing Silversea with Regent #186730 04/28/08 08:22 AM
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 3,407
Betty Offline
cruiser
Offline
cruiser
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 3,407
Agree with JoAnn. But I would be lost without my shower cap! I've had to call housekeeping on Regent for the same thing. Rule # 1 - Don't ever throw the cap out!
And I've seen Suzanne when she thought her hair was growing from the humidity. It wasn't, but she certainly thought it was. She looked as great as ever.


Betty
Re: Camel: Comparing Silversea with Regent #186731 04/28/08 12:01 PM
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 524
C
Canadagal Offline
cruiser
Offline
cruiser
C
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 524
Showercaps! That's one of my pet peeves both on cruiseships and in hotels. Why they don't automatically have them sitting on the counter when you check-in along with the soap and shampoo is what I find most annoying. Also, it bugs me when they don't replace them as needed. You would think that they were made of gold or something. If not why do you have to keep requesting them.
Suzanne, I'm so happy to hear that SS came to your door with a choice of toiletries. A practice I suspect they copied from Seabourn. That was the only thing that I had to complain about on my last SS cruise and that was that they were so stingey with replacing the shampoo, conditioner and soap just because it was the expensive Bvlgari stuff. One rationing was never enough and it was like pulling teeth trying to get more out of the stewardess. Now on Seabourn they came to your cabin the first day and left a basket full of everything and getting more was no problem. It's such a simple thing but to have to fight to get toiletries is ridiculous.
Pat

Re: Camel: Comparing Silversea with Regent #186732 04/29/08 04:26 PM
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 569
DebbieH103 Offline
cruiser
Offline
cruiser
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 569
Suzanne, we did have an experience like that once where we were told no early embarkation available in San Juan. We were staying across the street at Sheraton, so we walked over and got right on (paid the $100 pp). Next time in San Juan, we just went over. Then in Dubai, we loved our hotel too much to attempt early check-in, but others did it. I don't know if they booked it in advance or not.

The choice of toiletries came about when they took away the Bvulgari for Aqua de Parma and many were disappointed and made a huge deal of it. Then they started it back with a choice and added on Neutrogena. I like the Bvulgari best because the Aqua has a stronger scent.

I think the reason I like the service better on SS is it is a little more formal.

I'm interested in how Shadow compares to my experiences on the 3 other SS cruises we've had in the last 2 yrs. I am hoping it will be great with this being the end of the world cruise.

Tomorrow we opted for all-inclusive at The Verandah for the night, so we probably won't try to board early. We will see how we like The Verandah, and if unhappy will just go to the pier. I don't know how many booked 3809B vs. 3809, so I don't know if they are going to charge to board early or not.

I agree about the free internet, though I am not getting it yet on Regent. I spend hundreds on internet just so I can share my pics (and do other things, of course). I wish SS had this perk.

Re: Camel: Comparing Silversea with Regent #186733 04/29/08 05:44 PM
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 3,407
Betty Offline
cruiser
Offline
cruiser
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 3,407
Debbie - can a person ever reach a level on Silverseas to get free internet? I would have hated to see my bill the end of LAMB if I hadn't had free access & the upcoming SAMBA & then on to FLL. I think that's about 4 weeks. I could pay for another cruise for what that internet bill would be if not for that perk.
And I'll bring my own shower cap if needed! :D


Betty
Re: Camel: Comparing Silversea with Regent #186734 04/30/08 12:09 AM
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 569
DebbieH103 Offline
cruiser
Offline
cruiser
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 569
Normally, there are shower caps. I don't think they ever have free internet. You earn free laundry, a free week, etc. They have their 5% Venetian Society discounts, and after a while you get 10% off on your cruises. They have a little bit better referral program than Regent. You also earn free laundry. We buy 1000 minutes for a week to 10 days, so free internet would be a good deal for us. For our 5 night cruise tomorrow, we will likely get 500 minutes. We did enjoy the free laundry that came with our Medallion suite last time, and probably 3 times the last week, Todd has said, "we'll have free laundry, right"? Somehow he has in his head we are going to get free laundry from now on. Of course, we are not booked in Medallion.

Perhaps I will remember to put the suggestion of free internet on the comment card. Others should start doing that, too. I think the main reason they don't do it is the issue with people not signing off. If they improve the setup to nudge people off, maybe they can do this in the future. Wishful thinking?

Re: Camel: Comparing Silversea with Regent #186735 05/04/08 11:24 PM
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 2,026
Fogmalkin Offline
cruiser
Offline
cruiser
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 2,026
Not to beat a dead horse, but the odd shower cap 'issue' lasted the entire cruise. I brought the one from the hotel in Luxor back to the ship with me and had it hidden in my zipped makeup bag with the precious one given to me by the head of housekeeping. They both disappeared the next morning with no replacements!! I have never before had an attendent remove something and throw it away. I've had Regent room attendents dust around a tissue rather than toss it.

Again, no biggie, just odd. Also one attendent would hold up my clothes to her in front of the mirror. I only know about that because she would tell me. "Oh madam, you have zis be-u-tiful outfit. I held eet up and did za little shake-shake". I offered to loan her said outfit for her themed crew party and she was pleased as punch. I thought it would at least earn me a shower cap, but no... confused


Suzanne
Re: Camel: Comparing Silversea with Regent #186736 05/05/08 02:19 AM
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 569
DebbieH103 Offline
cruiser
Offline
cruiser
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 569
Really odd, on the shower cap. Maybe they needed to order?

With only 212 on this 382 passenger ship, nobody would have to hold a gun to our head about which line has better service, but I have found it better on all 4 cruises. Some would find this level annoying. There are more staff than guests, and some are looking for stuff to do. I love how they have let their hair down. I never thought I'd see bartenders with shirts off and in drag with pineapple bikini tops. Interesting activities here at the end of the world cruise.

I hope you guys are continuing to enjoy.

Did they put the massage chairs in the observation lounge on Whisper? Shadow has 6 now, and I discovered them yesterday. A small thrill, but it was something new, and I spent 25 minutes in one.

Re: Camel: Comparing Silversea with Regent #186737 05/07/08 01:43 PM
Joined: May 2004
Posts: 709
Freddie Offline
cruiser
Offline
cruiser
Joined: May 2004
Posts: 709
"I never thought I'd see bartenders with shirts off and in drag with pineapple bikini tops."

Yikes, that was not offered on our recent Whisper cruise. That would have been even better than the bartenders on the Regent Voyager crossing last year wearing cowboy duds for the Country Fair event. Now we're getting into serious Silversea vs. Regent territory...

Re: Camel: Comparing Silversea with Regent #186738 05/07/08 02:53 PM
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 7,646
ChatKat... Offline
cruiser
Offline
cruiser
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 7,646
Fred, you forgot about Mojito Boy?


VOYAGER:
MC to FLL 11/07
MC/Dover 6/06
MARINER:
BCN / Ven 10/11
Alaska 2001|2006
Panama Canal 2003
NAV
Caribbean 11/06
Bermuda|New Eng/Canada 6/04
PG 5/05
OCEANIA
Nautica |Ist/Athens 6/07
Regatta|Baltics 6/08
Riviera 2013 Crossing -Istanbul to Miami
Re: Camel: Comparing Silversea with Regent #186739 05/08/08 02:13 AM
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 4,215
adrenn Offline
cruiser
Offline
cruiser
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 4,215
No massage chairs in the observation lounge on Whisper, Debbie. Hopefully they add them on the next drydock.

Cheers, Anne

Re: Camel: Comparing Silversea with Regent #186740 05/08/08 06:18 AM
Joined: Jul 2004
Posts: 240
Island Cruiser Offline
cruiser
Offline
cruiser
Joined: Jul 2004
Posts: 240
This is my first time on the internet since leaving home. Loved reading all the interesting and worthwhile posts. On the basis of my experience on Whisper, I'd rate rate Regent and Silversea excellent and relatively equal. IMO, Silversea beats Regent in the areas of service and the travel desk. The service on Whisper was awesome. When we boarded, we found our forward cabin a bit too warm and asked that the air conditioning be checked out. It was checked out and proved to be ok. The next morning, when we returned to our cabin from breakfast, all three pairs (yes, pairs) of cabin attendants who worked the deck 8 cabins saw us and stopped what they were doing to ask us about the status of our air conditioning--all three. They ALL knew us and went out of their way to show they cared. That night, our second night on the ship, I walked into the Panorama Lounge after the show to order a cognac. It was placed in front of me in thirty seconds. My response: "That was fast." The waitress casually replied: "the bartender saw you walk in." Wow! By this time, by the way, we were regularly addressed by name by most of the crew members who dealt with us regularly.

I have found the tour desk on Regent ships to be the weak spot. The clerks seem bored and neither interested nor well informed about scheduled port stops and available excursions. The Whisper tour desk, in contrast, was excellent. The staff were involved, well informed, personable, and highly visible on the ship's tours doing their best keep folks happy. They made a real difference and a highly positive impression.

In most other respects, I found the Whisper experience to match the excellence I have enjoyed on Voyager and Mariner. The one problem on Whisper was, as others have correctly reported, the inconsistent galley. Lots of the Silversea regulars we talked to said this was unique to this executive chef and an exception to the rule.

It was a wonderful trip with excellent traveling companions. I hope to post a full review sometime soon.

Patrick

Re: Camel: Comparing Silversea with Regent #186741 05/08/08 09:21 AM
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 569
DebbieH103 Offline
cruiser
Offline
cruiser
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 569
I wonder if that is a new executive chef since December, as we didn't have any trouble on Whisper on either cruise, but on this Shadow cruise, I did see some change in sauces that didn't suit me.

Anne, thanks for clarifying on the massage chairs. I didn't think they had been added since December, and I assume they don't have the gold fabrics yet in the cabins and probably not the video screens in the gym. I hope they match Whisper match Shadow on those.

The service you all mention is what we are used to on SS and the reason I brag on it so much. We also like the fact that tours are escorted and the tour desk is dedicated. I did like on Regent on the tours I have been on how much they really worked on using local guides and including local foods and wines. It did seem to me to be something they really did well.

Freddie, that pineapple thing was the most relaxed thing I have seen on SS. My pics are a bit dark, but I hope when I get them up people can tell what they were about. There was also a Pink Panther presentation and one person that wore a captain's uniform. His was funny because the captain actually interrupted with a weather report, and it almost seemed choreographed. The 4th person had dressed like a dance host and had a staff member dressed in drag and did "All that Jazz". Out of the 212 on board, about 100 came to this event. I don't know if the guests won anything, as they joked that they got to take the head bartender's place for his vacation week.

Re: Camel: Comparing Silversea with Regent #186742 05/09/08 03:24 AM
Joined: Mar 2004
Posts: 3,415
Wandra Offline
cruiser
Offline
cruiser
Joined: Mar 2004
Posts: 3,415
Pat and Fred, any idea which David is on? Of CDB fame? Pat, sounds like you have a great time, good to hear your reports on SS.


Wendy
------
Booked: Uniworld Egypt, 2015
Tauck Amsterdam to Budapest, 2016
Paul Gauguin, Societies & Tuamotus 2016
Re: Camel: Comparing Silversea with Regent #186743 05/09/08 04:23 AM
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 4,395
southernlady Offline
cruiser
Offline
cruiser
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 4,395
Pat thanks for chiming in. I'll look forward to reading your review.


Donna

I write about active travel for baby boomers: www.myitchytravelfeet.com
Re: Camel: Comparing Silversea with Regent #186744 05/09/08 04:41 AM
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 4,369
Beth Offline
cruiser
Offline
cruiser
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 4,369
Pat, We received the same type of bar service on the Wind. After Rod, the bartender, found out how my mom liked her martini, he had one delivered to our table almost as we sat down. Yes, the service is excellent on Silversea.

Re: Camel: Comparing Silversea with Regent #186745 05/09/08 05:18 AM
Joined: May 2004
Posts: 709
Freddie Offline
cruiser
Offline
cruiser
Joined: May 2004
Posts: 709
Debbie - It was our impression (and that of the CC poster who reviewed the Singapore-Dubai cruise) that the Exec Chef was quite new to the Whisper, having joined the ship in March or so.

Wendy - I couldn't find out whether David Bilsland is still an Exec Chef with SS. None of the senior dining room staff on the Whisper recognized the name.

Re: Camel: Comparing Silversea with Regent #186746 05/09/08 06:35 AM
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 2,512
azgkrudi Offline
cruiser
Offline
cruiser
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 2,512
I love it when the bartenders have your favorite drink whipped up for you even before you sit down. We've experienced that on Silversea and Regent's Navigator, as well.


Kristin

Paul Gauguin's Tere Moana-12/14
Voyager-10/08, 11/10
Navigator-05/07, 5/09, 10/11
Paul Gauguin-6/06, 12/07
Silver Shadow-12/06
Silver Whisper-11/05, 12/04
Silver Wind-4/04

Moderated by  KarenS 

Keene Luxury Travel Offers
Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.7.3