Pincus, I am assuming that you already know that on the Voyager ( as opposed to Mariner where they are much bigger), those penthouse cabins are only 14 s.ft. bigger than regular cabins. You don't say why DH wants an A or B. I for one have not been convinced that butlers add much, especially on this ship where Penhouse cabins are so much smaller. You can get afternoon treats from room service in standard cabins. But I am value-oriented. I guess it is up to her. My preference is lower and mid-ship, since I am sea-sick prone.