Great review. Just a couple of comments. In the past couple of weeks I've read negative comments about Cruise Directors (Mariner and Voyager) -- just want to post a strong positive comment about the Cruise Director on the Navigator. Daniel was amazing -- greeted us in the hallway by the suite # we'll be in next year (and he helped us pick the suite).

We also had some difficulty with food on the Navigator -- it was just an "off" time (their head chef was on leave due to a death in her family). Glad to hear that you're thinking about PG -- really a lovely ship -- great food and service. The water is gorgeous -- even if you don't go into it.