Eric - I bought the same luggage for our next cruise - our TUMI did take a beating on our last trip to Italy and I had to choose Duct Tape or new luggage. I had bought a piece of the Kirkland before and liked it just as well.
Have a great cruise and enjoy that new luggage. Be sure to put some kind of unique identifcation on it. We use those luggage straps on the outside incase a zipper breaks and use a marker to write on those as well.
