The ships and service on Oceania are outstanding. Small ships with no lines. Good food. Spotlessly maintained.

Celebrity ships are huge. We did one on the Millennium when it was new. The ship was so poorly maintained - we had a sky suite and it was so disappointing. We had tile coming off the shower wall and mildew. We also had the marble etched from lemon juice on the dressing table left by the prior passenger so it never felt clean and stained carpet. And my bugaboo about bedsheets that are not tucked in or fitted that gives me the willies. The food was steamtabled and poorer quality. We abhor fixed seating dining. A concierge cabin on Oceania or higher is really nice next to anything on Celebrity. The only thing better on Celebrity is the entertainment, but, not enough of the rest of the experience for me to try again.