Jim, when they showed how they voted, Coach voted for Courtney. I will have to look on youtube to make sure but I am almost positive?

Editing to add, I just looked on CBS and Coach voted for Courtney.

Survivor tribal council vote

Oops! You are right.
Wonder what I thought I saw???? DUH!

Coach had a dilemma. He wouldn't vote directly against Rob because he felt honor bound or some such thing to Rob. Coach doesn't trust Russell and was pissed off that Jerry agreed to vote with Russell and then told Coach that she hoped he would join them. Coach; perhaps rightly, felt they should get rid of their weakest player. But the reality that I'm sure he realized was that his lone vote for Courtney was a vote against Rob. I think that's why Rob's parting comment to him was "you're a little man."

Well even if Coach voted for Rob, wouldn't that of ended up in a tie? Then they vote again and if it's still a tie, they pick a rock out of a bag to decide who goes home.
So Coach voting for Russel wouldn't of accomplished much.

You are right, Karen. It would have resulted in a tie. And a re-vote would probably (I'm not positive about Jerry) produce the same thing. If they then did the rock from a bag thing it's dumb luck who goes. Do they only do the making fire challenge to break a tie after the tribes have merged?

I forgot to post after the show on Thursday, I guess I was too dumbfounded! The other tribe gave Russel their immunity idol. HAHAHAAHAHAHAH I can't believe the only person who thought that was a dumb idea was Amanda.

I was jaw dropping stupified (I need a life), what was TJ? DJ? thinking??? and the whole tribe thought it a brilliant idea? :rolleyes:

Boy do the Heros have things wrong in the Villian camp huh!

As much as I dislike Russel I sure agree with his statement regarding the fact that JT gave him the Hero's immumity idol: "That has got to be the dumbest move in Survivor history!" (Or something similar to that.)

I have always liked JT, but I will never understand that bonehead move...wait'll the Heroes see that Courtney was voted out! JT will be saying "Oh CRAP" (or some other term ;) )

Guess who got arrested ???


Survivor Villan Collared

I still have an intense dislike towards Russell, but am glad that he is paranoid enough to have played an immunity idol when there was no need to do so and that his pride caused him to break up the Parvati/Danielle alliance.

There may actually still be some hope for Rupert or Colby.

Next weeks immunity will be very important.
If Colby or Rupert should win it that really
would change the numbers.
Still trying to decide if Russell made a big mistake when he was putting Parvati and Danielle against each other.
And Sandra with the hidden idol has not said much lately.

Yes Jim, I really hope that Rupert or Colby can win the next immunity and somehow also protect their buddy for the tribal council vote. Parvati sure is peeved with Russell right now but she also has as much determination to win as he does so she might stay in alliance with him if he turns his back on his most recent "alliance." Jerry's eyes are very expressive. She is going to stay busy trying to figure out which group to vote with.

Sandra knows when to lay low. She is also pretty good at hearing what is going on and looking out for herself. That's helpful to her since she is no good at winning challenges. I was pretty sure she won her season so I checked the cbs site and verified that she did win Pearl Islands.

Everybody ready for the finale? I don't mind if anyone wins except Sandra. For some reason she really annoys me, I think it's the mean look she always has on her face.

My dear Karen, I hope that you are not too upset. I would have loved it if Jerri or Colby had made it into the final 3. I'm OK with the winner because I felt anyone but Russell...

I started watching late & played catch-up. At 10:04 I realized that the recording light was not on. I quickly started recording the reunion show at that point but the 4 minutes I missed were when the votes were tallied. Was the win by a vote of 6-3 or 5-4?

I can't remember Kathy, I think Jeff stopped reading the votes when Sandra got enough?
I agree, I would of rather seen Jerri win!

I watched until the final minute, (thanks Karen for sending me heads up!)I think Sandra had the sympathy vote because of her husband. All Survivors cleaned up to look like "Stars" except Russell and Rupert. Can't wait for new season.

Nobody thought Sandra had a chance. "Would not get a single vote". Boy were they wrong huh?
Russell was mad again that he did not win.
I would have liked to have seen Jerri win.

Russell does all the right things to get himself to the end but refuses to appeal to the "human" side of the jury after that. It's kind of a shame! I wanted Jerri to win, too - I was surprised at that! She has changed SOOO much since her Survivor debut. Is it just me or is she prettier out in the wild than when she colors her hair and loads on the makeup???

I am glad that Rupert didn't win the 100K prize, he is another one that annoys me with all the whining and odd staring.

I agree Kristin, I thought Jerri looked prettier in the wild That is a hard thing to do as I would look like one of those troll dolls after the first day, lol

Karen, I was wondering how she can keep those long ringlets looking so good after 5+ weeks without any "products"! I go one day w/o shampooing and I look like a drowned rat! LOL