All of the above are excellent. Also consider Wicked with Kirsten Chenoweth (Nomminated for Best Actress) and Idina Mazell(sp?) (who won the Tony for Actress). We are still singing the songs!
Also enjoyed dinner at Blue Fin (Fish restaurant in Times Square), Felidia (Italian-modern, Four Seasons, and La Grenouille.
I also enjoyed the Frick Collection Museum and always enjoy the Metropolian Museum. The Grayline Tours where you can hop on and off the bus all day to see the various sites is good. The Midtown tour is $37.00 and you can hop on and off for two full days.