Thanks JHP! We went to Alaska last year on HAL and it was perfect! From the room, to the butler service and all the amenities that went with it. Also, we've been spoiled ever since our PG cruise a few years ago to the Society Islands, which was my most favorite. I was just concerned since Regent took over Radisson and then reading the reviews made me wonder if we should go back to HAL for the Caribbean cruise. That said, even on HAL we noticed plumbing/garbage odors on some of the lower decks. Had we been on those decks, we would have had to be moved to a different location or leave, as I'm certain it would set off my husband's asthma!!! But, fingers crossed, the Navigator will be OK, especially after dry dock. We don't sail until April. It's for 11 nights, so hopefully all will go well. Thanks for the input!