Hi all,

We've been on 2 Oceania cruises, both with dear Claudia, so I'd be happy to add my POV as well. However, I've not cruised w/ RSSC (yet) so can't compare the two.

Ngaire - you wrote, "they both have open seating and you know how I feel about that". Since I don't know you well, how DO you feel about open seating. Like or dislike? DH and I prefer it.

Jim B - What is it about Oceania's tipping policy that you don't like? We think it's terrific.

CJ