Marc,
Our Caribbean cruise in January on silverseas was less per diem than a similar Radisson cruise. When it works i guess it works. If you consider all inclusive an upgrade of class, well then they are. We really did like that, no doubt, and would go again in a minute for that reason alone. I would say all else is similar, also we asked for and got caviar at no cost. I'm not sure if that was an oversight or not. it really was fabulous, but not a whole lot else stands out. i think once you get to the level of Radisson, it's hard to raise the bar in huge increments.

Cindy