ChatKat,
Thanks for your reply. We are looking at Concierge Cats....thanks for your validation. We're concerned that signing for drinks and paying tips might lower our pleasure but sounds like you had a good experience on BOTH cruises.
Did you find the Oceania Concierge cabins much smaller than the PG's? They're about 30 sq ft less but wondering if you noticed much difference.....well, I guess I should have asked if you were in a F-C Cat on the PG otherwise you wouldn't have a comparison, would you? LOL....