LeeAnne - Even though you have to buy your own beverages, Windstar holds a very fond memory for me - I loved it. Just BYOB, sit/lay on the deck, open your special bottle of wine and enjoy the stars with your DH. The nights on deck were very special. I think you will love the crew. They also had very good deck/beach picnics when we cruised them. Great passengers.
Have a wonderful cruise. Let us know how it goes, I will be anxious to hear your review for it has been a long time since I sailed Windstar.

Sally